The painting, created for the church of Santa Caterina Martire by the Olivetan Benedictines of Fabriano, depicts a miraculous event repeated several times in the life of Saint Frances of Rome (1384-1440): receiving the Baby Jesus from the hands of the Virgin Mary, seated on ethereal clouds. The not-so-young Frances, traditionally accompanied by her guardian angel, lovingly cradles the Child, who tenderly caresses her face. The episode is reported in the biography written by the saint’s confessor, Giovanni Mattiotti, and in that of Friar Ippolito da Roma. These are reliable sources for the painting executed by Orazio Gentileschi, who reproduces the brightness of the angelic hosts and depicts the Baby as though he were about eight months old.
Iconographically, the canvas has two 15th-century predecessors in Rome, which Gentileschi undoubtedly studied. The first was created a few years after the saint’s death as part of a series of panels depicting her life and visions, originating from the Olivetan church of Santa Maria Nuova. The second was made shortly after her beatification in 1460 in a cycle of frescoes painted by Antoniazzo and his workshop in the old church of Tor de Specchi, where, in 1433, the community of Benedictine oblates founded by Frances had its origins.
The Fabriano church of Santa Caterina Martire was radically renovated between 1590 and 1620, so it can be hypothesized that the altarpiece was created toward the end of this period.
During the Napoleonic era, the painting managed to escape confiscation and likely passed to Silvestro Marcellini, the abbot who continued to live in the Olivetan monastery, albeit suppressed, under the protection of the government’s property officer Carlo Rosei, who inherited the abbot’s collection upon his death. In 1941, the couple Ugo and Carolina Agabiti Rosei sold the painting to the Italian state, which then destined it for the National Gallery of the Marches.
The critical history of the painting, unanimously considered one of Gentileschi’s masterpieces, began in 1916 with Roberto Longhi, who regarded the canvas as “one of the first works to succeed based on values rather than colors.” The work is indeed one of the earliest paintings to explore the relationships between color, light, and form, which form the basis of modern painting up to the Impressionism of Monet and Renoir.
The simplicity of composition and meticulous attention to detail in the painting, as in other works by Orazio in the Marche region, have led critics to suggest influences from Florentine art, Santi di Tito, 15th-century masters, and Marche painting by Lotto. According to Keith Christiansen (2001), this demonstrates that the visual language of the painter expresses “the context in which the everyday is pervaded by the divine,” aligning with “a very close dependence on Counter-Reformation positions on religious art,” such as those held by the more conservative Giovan Andrea Gilio of Fabriano. Gentileschi likely assimilated these positions during his youth in Pisa and Rome between 1580 and 1590. Notably, the altarpiece for the Olivetans by Gentileschi adheres to “the two twin principles of faithfulness to the historical source—whether biblical or hagiographical—and a sense of decorum and propriety,” defended by Gilio in his dialogue on art abuses published in 1564. The manifestation of the divine intrudes into the everyday world, exemplified by the well-worn steps, the saint’s slippers, portrayed as a matron, and the prayer book. Furthermore, the duality between the metaphysical and the real is fully captured in the contrast between the golden light originating from the angelic hosts in the background and the strong, realistic light coming from the right, brilliantly illuminating the faces and draperies of the characters. The magical result achieved by Orazio can lead us to agree with Christiansen, stating that “with this work, Caravaggesque realism takes on a new devotional as well as aesthetic character.”
Author: Orazio Gentileschi
Realization date: 1618-1620
Storage location: Urbino, Galleria Nazionale delle Marche
INV COD:D 96
Dimensions: 270 x 157 cm
Technique: Oil on canvas
Author: Orazio Gentileschi
Realization date: 1618-1620
Storage location: Urbino, Galleria Nazionale delle Marche
INV COD:D 96
Dimensions: 270 x 157 cm
Technique: Oil on canvas
The painting, created for the church of Santa Caterina Martire by the Olivetan Benedictines of Fabriano, depicts a miraculous event repeated several times in the life of Saint Frances of Rome (1384-1440): receiving the Baby Jesus from the hands of the Virgin Mary, seated on ethereal clouds. The not-so-young Frances, traditionally accompanied by her guardian angel, lovingly cradles the Child, who tenderly caresses her face. The episode is reported in the biography written by the saint’s confessor, Giovanni Mattiotti, and in that of Friar Ippolito da Roma. These are reliable sources for the painting executed by Orazio Gentileschi, who reproduces the brightness of the angelic hosts and depicts the Baby as though he were about eight months old.
Iconographically, the canvas has two 15th-century predecessors in Rome, which Gentileschi undoubtedly studied. The first was created a few years after the saint’s death as part of a series of panels depicting her life and visions, originating from the Olivetan church of Santa Maria Nuova. The second was made shortly after her beatification in 1460 in a cycle of frescoes painted by Antoniazzo and his workshop in the old church of Tor de Specchi, where, in 1433, the community of Benedictine oblates founded by Frances had its origins.
The Fabriano church of Santa Caterina Martire was radically renovated between 1590 and 1620, so it can be hypothesized that the altarpiece was created toward the end of this period.
During the Napoleonic era, the painting managed to escape confiscation and likely passed to Silvestro Marcellini, the abbot who continued to live in the Olivetan monastery, albeit suppressed, under the protection of the government’s property officer Carlo Rosei, who inherited the abbot’s collection upon his death. In 1941, the couple Ugo and Carolina Agabiti Rosei sold the painting to the Italian state, which then destined it for the National Gallery of the Marches.
The critical history of the painting, unanimously considered one of Gentileschi’s masterpieces, began in 1916 with Roberto Longhi, who regarded the canvas as “one of the first works to succeed based on values rather than colors.” The work is indeed one of the earliest paintings to explore the relationships between color, light, and form, which form the basis of modern painting up to the Impressionism of Monet and Renoir.
The simplicity of composition and meticulous attention to detail in the painting, as in other works by Orazio in the Marche region, have led critics to suggest influences from Florentine art, Santi di Tito, 15th-century masters, and Marche painting by Lotto. According to Keith Christiansen (2001), this demonstrates that the visual language of the painter expresses “the context in which the everyday is pervaded by the divine,” aligning with “a very close dependence on Counter-Reformation positions on religious art,” such as those held by the more conservative Giovan Andrea Gilio of Fabriano. Gentileschi likely assimilated these positions during his youth in Pisa and Rome between 1580 and 1590. Notably, the altarpiece for the Olivetans by Gentileschi adheres to “the two twin principles of faithfulness to the historical source—whether biblical or hagiographical—and a sense of decorum and propriety,” defended by Gilio in his dialogue on art abuses published in 1564. The manifestation of the divine intrudes into the everyday world, exemplified by the well-worn steps, the saint’s slippers, portrayed as a matron, and the prayer book. Furthermore, the duality between the metaphysical and the real is fully captured in the contrast between the golden light originating from the angelic hosts in the background and the strong, realistic light coming from the right, brilliantly illuminating the faces and draperies of the characters. The magical result achieved by Orazio can lead us to agree with Christiansen, stating that “with this work, Caravaggesque realism takes on a new devotional as well as aesthetic character.”





